Breer's QB poll

Sports · Heat 2.9 / 10 · 2 shows · 10m airtime

Albert Breer polled 17 NFL executives and coaches connected to the quarterback position over a few hours on October 28, 2026, and 12 said they would take Caleb Williams over Drake Maye. Williams' backers cite playmaking and clutch play; Maye's cite makeup and pocket progress. Most agreed the two are the best quarterbacks to enter the league since Joe Burrow in 2020. The discussion has since turned to the makeup of the sample: six GMs, five offensive coordinators, four assistant GMs, a VP of player personnel and a past game coordinator. What remains open is how much weight that mix carries.

How 2 podcasts covered it

1. The Herd with Colin Cowherd, 2026-10-28 (8:40 to 10:54)
   Reports a 17-evaluator quarterback poll
   Breer walks through his informal poll of 17 quarterback evaluators: 12 take Caleb Williams over Drake Maye, with the split framed as close and the two named the best passers to enter the league since Joe Burrow.
   New angle: 12 of 17 NFL executives and coaches polled would take Caleb Williams over Drake Maye.
2. First Things First, 2026-10-28 (18:52 to 26:43)
   Breaks down the poll's makeup and timing
   Breaks down the straw poll's makeup - six GMs, five OCs, four assistant GMs, a VP of player personnel and a past game coordinator - and notes it was taken before the Thursday game. The rest is debate over Williams versus Maye, with one host picking Maye.
   New angle: The 17 polled were six GMs, five OCs, four assistant GMs, a VP of player personnel and a past game coordinator.