Jonathan Taylor trade talk

Sports · Heat 7.7 / 10 · 7 shows · 50m airtime

The Indianapolis Colts lost to the Minnesota Vikings 10-6 on October 25, 2026, dropping to 2-5. That night, Jonathan Taylor's wife posted a viral Instagram video calling for the team to trade him. The discussion has moved from whether a spouse should speak publicly to the football case and the price: Jeff Saturday says he would trade Taylor if the price is right, arguing a rebuilding team should not lean on a back for 300-plus touches, while Pelissero expects a package a little under the McCaffrey haul of a second, third, fourth and fifth. Taylor has said no one in the Colts locker room is waving a white flag and that he must rally younger players after losing two captains.…

How 7 podcasts covered it

The Herd with Colin Cowherd, 2026-10-26 (30:17 to 32:44)
Debates a trade after Taylor's wife's post
Turns a viral Instagram post from Jonathan Taylor's wife into a trade debate after the Colts' 10-6 loss to the Vikings dropped them to 2-5. Fournette argues a spouse speaking publicly hurts a player's market, and points to Cleveland's 5-2 record after moving Myles Garrett.
New angle: Jonathan Taylor's wife posted a viral Instagram video calling for a trade.
First Take, 2026-10-28 (6:34 to 14:42)
Debates the trade and names two fits
Debates whether the Colts should move Jonathan Taylor, naming the Vikings and Broncos as fits and arguing the August extension and his face-of-the-franchise status cut against a deal. Stays inside the trade talk already on the record, with a detour into Kevin O'Connell's quarterback handling.
The Dan Patrick Show, 2026-10-28 (23:38 to 28:57)
Plays the where-should-Taylor-land parlor game
Runs a parlor game of where Jonathan Taylor should land if the Colts move him - Denver, Houston, Jacksonville, Minnesota, the Giants - and wanders into McCaffrey's return, Barkley and Brown trades inside a division, and a Nixon-Carter detour. Speculation, not a development.
The Rich Eisen Show, 2026-10-28 (11:25 to 13:09)
Argues Houston should buy into the Taylor market
Runs the Texans' deadline question through the Jonathan Taylor market: Houston should buy, not sell, but the Colts would want a premium to send Taylor inside the division. Opinion and framing, no new reporting.
The Rich Eisen Show, 2026-10-28 (14:24 to 16:05)
Explains the Colts' asking price for Taylor
Rapoport says the Colts view Jonathan Taylor as part of the rebuild, so any deal would cost more than the Nelson return. The hosts use the Jets' teardown as the comparison for what Indianapolis is about to endure.
First Things First, 2026-10-28 (1:25:10 to 1:28:33)
Floats four fits for the top back
Trade-deadline segment that treats Jonathan Taylor as the headliner available back, with Seattle, Denver, Cincinnati and Minnesota floated as fits. It stays inside the trade chatter already on the record and adds only the hosts' preferences.
The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL, 2026-10-29 (31:45 to 37:01)
Runs through landing spots for Taylor
Runs through landing spots for a Jonathan Taylor trade, naming Minnesota and Cincinnati as the most plausible and ruling out Seattle after the Nelson deal. Frames the Giants as a multi-year fit rather than a 2026 finishing piece, and argues deadline buying rarely works for teams like New York and Cleveland.
The Herd with Colin Cowherd, 2026-10-29 (7:08 to 15:13)
Debates Taylor's value against the McCaffrey deal
Debates Taylor's trade value against the McCaffrey deal and names Denver, Seattle, New York, Minnesota and Cincinnati as landing spots, with Minnesota the best fit. Opinion and prediction built on the trade talk already on the record.
The Rich Eisen Show, 2026-10-29 (19:23 to 24:48)
Argues a rebuild should trade Taylor
Jeff Saturday, the former Colts coach and player, walks through the rebuild and says he would trade Jonathan Taylor if the number is right, framing it as a value call on a back who would take 300-plus touches on a team years from contending.
New angle: Jeff Saturday would trade Jonathan Taylor if the price is right, saying a rebuilding team should not lean on a back for 300-plus touches.
The Rich Eisen Show, 2026-10-29 (6:27 to 9:12)
Works through the tanking math on Taylor
Plays Taylor's own comments about being proud to wear the horseshoe and not controlling trade rumors, then works through the tanking math: the Colts' first-rounder belongs to the Jets, so losing only helps New York unless a Taylor trade buys a pick back. Stays inside the trade case already on the record.
The Rich Eisen Show, 2026-10-29 (9:40 to 12:25)
Plays Taylor's answer on waving no white flag
Plays Taylor's own answer to a reporter asking whether he is okay being part of a rebuild: he says nobody in the locker room is waving a white flag and that losing two captains means he has to rally the younger players. The hosts use that answer as their case against trading him.
New angle: Taylor said no one in the Colts locker room is waving a white flag and he must rally younger players after losing two captains.
The Bill Simmons Podcast, 2026-10-30 (25:17 to 26:41)
Reports a Taylor package just under the McCaffrey haul
Pelissero's quick read on the Taylor market: the package would land a little under the McCaffrey haul of a second, third, fourth and fifth, and he does not see Minnesota making that splash with Dallas Turner and others waiting on extensions.
New angle: Pelissero expects a Taylor package a little under the McCaffrey haul of a second, third, fourth and fifth.
The Rich Eisen Show, 2026-10-30 (5:04 to 6:25)
Reports the Colts' price and Minnesota intrigue
Fowler reports the Colts are not actively shopping Taylor but would move him at the right price, and floats Minnesota as the team league people are most intrigued by at 6-0. He frames the return as McCaffrey-like: no first-rounder, but a real package.
New angle: Fowler says the Colts are not actively shopping Taylor, and Minnesota is the team people around the league are most intrigued by.