Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

@crimestorieswithnancygrace · Podcast

Latest segments

• Irene Miller charged, 2026-10-29
  Recaps the arrest and the babysitter account
  First coverage of the Osceola County case: the 911 call about an injured nine-year-old, the three siblings left unsupervised, and Miller's account of a Tampa babysitter who was not required to stay overnight. Miller was arrested at the airport on her return from Las Vegas.
• Alexander brothers sentencing, 2026-10-29
  Reports the 30-year sentences and courtroom remarks
  Reports the sentencing itself: Judge Caproni gave each of the three brothers 30 years on October 27, after prosecutors sought life and the defense asked for 15. Adds the U.S. attorney's statement and the brothers' remarks in court.
• Tennessee's Krista Pike execution, 2026-10-28
  Recalls Slemmer as kind and calls for execution
  A friend of Colleen Slemmer remembers her as kind and helpful, says her mother has never had closure, and calls for Pike to be executed soon. Reaction and victim-family framing, with no new development in the case.
• Tennessee execution chief resigns, 2026-10-28
  Frames officials as a mean-girl pack
  Marshall uses the mean-girl pack frame to compare Pike's killing group with the officials who ran the execution, then repeats Fowler's central-line admission already on the record. The rest is setup for the Rita Morris interview.
• Tennessee's Krista Pike execution, 2026-10-28
  Interviews Slemmer's friend from the dorm
  Brings on Rita Morris, a friend of Colleen Slemmer from the Job Corps dorm, who retells the skull-fragment display and the jealousy over Shipp. It adds a first-hand voice but no fact the record does not already hold.
• Pike execution fails, 2026-10-28
  Recaps the August hearing via The Tennessean
  Recaps the August hearing through The Tennessean's Keith Sharon: the central line was Pike's first alternative, and the defense argued a doctor's qualifications would be litigated endlessly. Stays inside the record already laid out, then turns to the cognition claim.
• Pike execution fails, 2026-10-28
  Debates central line versus surgical port
  A nurse-attorney and a doctor debate whether a central line or a surgical port should have been used for Pike's execution, with the nurse arguing the drug went into tissue and burned. Opinion and explanation of how the methods work, not a development in the case.
• Tennessee's Krista Pike execution, 2026-10-28
  Reads the brutality as rage and dominance
  A psychoanalyst reads the murder's brutality as rage and dominance, saying Pike saw Slemmer as a rival for her boyfriend, and argues the state has disrespected May Martinez by denying her grandchildren. Interpretation and reaction, not new record.
• Krista Pike back in prison, 2026-10-28
  Traces the history of judicial hanging
  Runs through the history of judicial hanging in America - colonial import, the 1862 mass hanging of 38 Dakota men, Judge Parker - to frame Pike's hanging request. Background and context, not a development in the case.
• Krista Pike back in prison, 2026-10-28
  Reports no one in Tennessee can hang
  Turns to the hanging alternative Pike's lawyers raised and explains the mechanics: weight, height and rope length must be calculated to snap the neck. Reports that Tennessee has no one qualified to perform a hanging, and that a correct drop takes 30 to 45 seconds.
• Pike execution fails, 2026-10-28
  Asks why no sedative preceded pentobarbital
  Grace asks the medical examiner why no pre-anesthetic sedative like propofol preceded the pentobarbital. Maroney blames cost-saving, walks through the three-drug protocol and recommends Tennessee use all three drugs with qualified personnel. Opinion and explanation, not a development in the case.
• Pike execution fails, 2026-10-28
  Adds compromised veins from substance use
  Brings on a medical examiner to explain the three-drug protocol Tennessee abandoned and to argue the single-drug pentobarbital method was the flaw. He adds that Pike's history of substance use disorder left her veins compromised, making superficial IV access the wrong choice.
• Tennessee execution chief resigns, 2026-10-28
  Adds a higher needle count than the record
  Runs through the failures of other methods - Florida's electric chair and its three-jolt executions - and has Keith Sharon explain that Pike's request for hanging was a required legal alternative to lethal injection, not a preference. Adds a higher needle count than the record holds.
• Tennessee's Krista Pike execution, 2026-10-28
  Recounts the 1995 murder and plays the mother
  Recounts the 1995 murder - the stabbing, the pentagram, the asphalt blow - and plays an interview with Colleen Slemmer's mother, who says no one has apologized and that a piece of her daughter's skull was never found. Stays inside the case record already on file.
• Krista Pike back in prison, 2026-10-28
  Adds the Supreme Court rejecting the requests
  Opens on the commutation question and adds a specific court action: Pike's lawyers asked for an all-female execution team and for hanging instead of injection, and the Tennessee Supreme Court turned them down. The governor still has not announced a decision.
• The Clancy verdict watch, 2026-10-27
  Reads the text exchange into the record
  Reads the January 24, 2023 text exchange between the Clancys from Trooper Ciappini's sworn testimony, then plays Reddington's claim that Clancy was told what happened after her coma. Marshall calls the defense malingering, arguing Clancy asked for a phone on the first hospital visit and immediately described command hallucinations.
• Lindsay Clancy's Zoloft start, 2026-10-27
  Argues the medication timeline shows seeking
  Psychoanalyst Bethany Marshall walks through the medication sequence - Zoloft triggering a manic episode, then Lamictal and sleep aids - and argues Clancy kept seeking new drugs before any could work. Opinion and framing built on the medication timeline already on the record.
• The Clancy verdict watch, 2026-10-27
  Explains ligature strangulation mechanics
  Brings on the Dallas County medical examiner to walk through the mechanics of ligature strangulation with elastic bands: the victim must be within arm's length, the airway and vessels are occluded, and death takes seconds to minutes. It is an explainer that stays inside the trial's strangulation testimony.
• The Clancy mistrial, 2026-10-27
  Argues Rule 106 kept the suit out
  Argues the civil filing's line that Patrick had left to pick up food undercuts theories blaming him, then explains why prosecutors stayed away: under Rule 106 the whole lawsuit, written by her lawyers to show insanity, would come in. Stays inside the civil-suit thread already on the record.
• The Clancy verdict watch, 2026-10-27
  Explains how device data places her
  Brings on a certified forensic analyst to explain, in general terms, how phone GPS, watch data and home IoT devices could place Clancy in the house during the searches. It is method, not new evidence, and stays inside the trial record.